Creatine Gummies vs Powder: Which One Actually Works?

Creatine is having a serious moment right now! From bodybuilders to busy mums, we’re all being told to jump on the creatine bandwagon to  improve our strength, muscle mass and performance.

And to sweeten the deal, creatine is now available in the form of convenient and tasty gummies 

 that claim to give us the same muscle boosting powers and benefits as the powder. 

But is that actually true?

And should everyone really be taking creatine?

What Exactly Is Creatine?

First things first—why is creatine all the rage? Found naturally in our muscles, creatine helps generate energy for those intense, short bursts of exercise. It's one of the most researched supplements for improving strength, muscle mass, and performance but not everyone needs to jump on the creatine train.  It’s not a one size fits all solution and we need to be far more strategic when it comes to supplementing with creatine.

Gummies vs. Powder

The allure of creatine gummies is pretty obvious —they’re convenient and delicious. But you’ll pay for it. Here in Australia, one brand like Push Gummies costs a whopping $1.67 per serve. Compare that to the range of $0.20 to $0.80 per serve for creatine powder, and you’re looking at eight times the cost! Do you really want to blow over $600 a year when powder sets you back just $73?

Independent Testing Reveals Inconsistencies

In 2024, NOW Foods did some independent testing of 12  brands of creatine gummies by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to see how much creatine is actually in each gummy compared to what is on the label. 

Out of the 12 brands tested, six of them didn't contain the amount of creatine that was claimed to be on the label. In fact, one brand had none whatsoever. So you’re basically just buying expensive lollies.

Creatine Powder Gets My Vote For Now

The science remains clear: traditional creatine monohydrate powder is still the gold standard. It's cost-effective, stable, reliable and backed by decades of research. You can measure it precisely, ensuring you're getting exactly what you need for optimal performance.

Until gummy manufacturers can prove their products deliver consistent, stable doses of creatine (with transparent testing to back it up), your best bet is sticking with proven powder forms and saving your money. 

LINKS:

NOW testing: Testing programme identifies creatine gummy failings

Other articles you may be interested in:

What is a Sports Dietitian?

Estimate your sweat rate: New free tool! With Lindsey Hunt

Hall Of Fame Swimmer Turned Triathlete: Chad Rolfs On Training, Racing And Nutrition

What Leanne has learnt from 18 Ironmans!

Top 10 Superfoods for Endurance Athletes

How Long Does It Take to Prep for a Triathlon? Insights from a Triathlon Dietitian

Unveiling the Secrets of a Triathlete's Diet

New research that's blown everything we knew about protein out of the water